|
Pros / Cons
Advantages:
- High rate of production.
- High accuracy in sustaining dimensions part to part.
- Smooth surface finish for minimum mechanical finishing.
- Able to incorporate cast-in details as holes, openings, slots,
trademarks, numbers, etc,..
- Intricate shapes and details don't add to the cost of production
once the die is constructed.
- Can produce thinner walls than those produced by other casting
processes.
- Able to cast in inserts such as pins, studs, shafts, linings,
bushings, fasteners, strengtheners, and heating elements.
- Uses a range of alloys that fit many design requirements.
Disadvantages:
- Dies are complicated and costly to construct so that high rates
of usage are needed to justify the use of this process.
- As the die is filled violently and solidification happens quickly,
typically within half a second, air and die lubricant can be trapped
in the cavity. This results in microporosity in the castings.
- Generally, walls and other details perpendicular to the parting
line can not be made since taper is needed to get the part out
of the die. This problem can be solved for by use of expensive
core slides.
Source: Bralla,
Design for Manufacturing Handbook.
Following is a comparative
table of the advantages and disadvantages of all metal casting processes
discussed in MAS.
SOME
CASTING PROCESSES, THEIR ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS
| PROCESS |
ADVANTAGES |
LIMITATIONS |
| Die
Casting |
Excellent
dimesional accuracy and surface finish; high production rate. |
Die cost
is high; part size limited; usually limited to non ferrous metals;
long lead time. |
| Investment
Casting |
Intricate
shapes;excellent surface finish and accuracy; almost any metal
cast. |
Part size
limited; expensive patterns, mold, and labor. |
| Sand
Casting |
Almost
any metal is cast; no limit to size, shape or weight; low tooling
cost. |
Some finishing
required; somewhat coarse finish; wide tolerances. |
| Shell
mold |
Good dimensional
accuracy and surface finish; high production rate. |
Part size
limited; expensive patterns and equipment required. |
|